quality tools | Project Success

Click the video above to view

Mastering Quality Management Tools in Project Management: A Practical Guide

Quality management is at the heart of every successful project, ensuring that products or services meet the necessary standards and satisfy customer needs. In this article, we will dive into the six essential quality management tools that every project manager must know, with practical examples from the “Pet Buddy” project.

1. Test and Inspection Plan (Test & Evaluation Documents)

The first quality management tool in our toolkit is the Test and Inspection Plan. This tool outlines how testing will be conducted throughout the project, including acceptance criteria and the deliverables that need to be tested. In the Pet Buddy project, Macy, the test lead, and Jack, the tester, are responsible for creating these documents. The acceptance criteria define the steps needed for a deliverable to pass or fail the test.

Acceptance Criteria can be a series of steps to a requirement goal, or could be in the format of “Given, When, Then,” or “As a,” “I Want,” “So I can”.

2. Control Charts

Once testing begins, monitoring the performance of processes is vital, which is where Control Charts come into play. In the Pet Buddy project, a control chart was used to track pet booking vs. cancellations. The chart visually displays data to determine if processes are within an acceptable range, showing whether bookings are performing as expected or if cancellations are becoming an issue.

The chart includes an average line and control limits—often set at three standard deviations from the average. However, in practical terms, the chart may be adjusted for more sensitivity to monitor performance more effectively. If the data points fall outside of the control limits, it’s time for a deeper investigation into the cause of the variations.

3. Check Sheets

When defects occur, tracking them efficiently is essential. Check Sheets provide a simple yet powerful way to collect and categorize defects. In Pet Buddy, Macy and Jack use a check sheet to record defects such as booking failures, app freezes, and display issues. By tallying the defects, the team can quickly identify patterns and prioritize actions based on the frequency and severity of the issues.

4. Pareto Charts

A more advanced version of the check sheet is the Pareto Chart. This tool takes the defects recorded in the check sheet and organizes them from largest to smallest, highlighting the most common or impactful problems. In the Pet Buddy example, the Pareto Chart showed that a sitter availability mismatch was the leading defect, causing the most significant number of issues.

This chart leverages the Pareto Principle, which states that 80% of the problems come from 20% of the causes. By focusing on the top 20% of defects, the team can address the core issues that will lead to the greatest improvements. The Pareto Chart gives the project team a clear focus, ensuring that efforts are concentrated on solving the most critical problems.

5. Ishikawa Diagram (Fishbone Diagram)

Once the team identifies the defects to work on, the next step is root cause analysis, and this is where the Ishikawa Diagram (also known as the Fishbone Diagram) comes into play. This tool helps in identifying the underlying causes of a problem by visualizing the various potential factors that contribute to it.

In the case of the sitter availability mismatch in the Pet Buddy project, the team uses the Ishikawa diagram to explore the different categories of potential causes: People, Information, Process, and System. This structured brainstorming approach uncovers the root causes of the problem, helping the team determine the most effective solutions.

6. The Five Whys

An alternative method for root cause analysis is the Five Whys technique. This tool involves asking “why” repeatedly until the root cause is uncovered. For example, when analyzing glitches in the booking logic of the Pet Buddy app, the team might ask why the glitch is happening. The initial answer might be that the system allows two pet owners to book the same sitter at overlapping times. But by asking why further, the team uncovers that the true root cause is a lack of proper concurrency control in the booking system.

This iterative questioning helps dig deeper into the problem, ensuring that the actual cause is addressed, rather than just the symptoms.

Conclusion

Quality management is an ongoing process throughout the life of a project. From identifying defects and monitoring performance to uncovering root causes and implementing solutions, the tools we’ve discussed—Test & Evaluation Documents, Control Charts, Check Sheets, Pareto Charts, Ishikawa Diagrams, and the Five Whys—are essential for maintaining the highest standards.

In the Pet Buddy project, these tools allowed the team to identify and address issues early, improve the user experience, and ensure that the final product met both business goals and customer expectations. Whether you’re working on a small project or a large-scale initiative, these quality management tools will help you deliver successful outcomes, just like Pet Buddy’s project team did.

David McLachlan on LinkedIn

See more Project Tool articles:

You can see what people are saying about David McLachlan here: REVIEWS

Navigate to Free Project Management and Leadership Articles through the links on the right (or at the bottom if on Mobile)